It’s Banned Books Week! It looks like the results for 2009′s most frequently banned books isn’t out for a few more months, but the top ten lists for prior years is available.
2008′s most frequently banned book, for the third year in a row:

And Tango Makes Three, by Justin Richardson and Peter Parnell
Reasons: anti-ethnic, anti-family, homosexuality, religious viewpoint, and unsuited to age group
Wait, what the hell? How can a story about cute penguins be anti-ethnic? (As it turns out, Maus, the Pulitzer Prize-winning graphic novel memoir about the Holocaust, also sans human characters, was similarly charged with being anti-ethnic.) I mean, yeah, “anti-family” is code for “GAYGAYGAY!!!” and it could offend your “religious viewpoint” if you view gay people as subhuman freaks, but anti-ethnic? Penguins? Huh?
Social Justice Librarian looked into the matter of anti-ethnic gay penguins:
I did hear back from the ALA OIF in response to my previously posted follow-up questions, and in summary:
- they can’t tell us what type of institution the “anti-ethnic” charge came from (but I assume it has to be public or school library, and more likely a school)
- but they can tell us it happened in North Carolina
- they don’t know of any books beyond Maus and Tango that have been charged as anti-ethnic but have non-human characters
- they’re not sure how the anti-ethnic category came to be, and
- it’s entirely possible that it was checked off by mistake on the report form for And Tango Makes Three